Research progress & public evidence 科研进展与公开证据

Physics-to-Math
Research Observatory

物理—数学科研进展与证据看板

Explore what the Skill has built, which mathematical claims have been reviewed, what evidence supports its behavior, and which scientific questions remain open.

了解 Skill 已建立的研究能力、经过审查的数学命题、现有行为验证证据,以及仍然开放的科学问题。

Reviewed Papers已审查论文

2

Completed limited-scope mathematical audits.

已完成限定范围数学审查。

Core Protocol核心规范

4 Rules

Frozen methodological rules; not an empirical capability score.

已冻结的方法规范,不是能力评分。

Skill Validation能力验证

Incremental Gain Not Established稳定增量收益尚未证明

Historical evaluations exist, but they do not establish reliable general improvement.

已有历史评估,但尚未证明可靠的一般性增量收益。

Discipline Adapters学科适配

Experimental实验性

Optional discipline guidance; its incremental value remains under evaluation.

可选学科指导,增量价值仍待检验。

Selected research / 精选研究

Research Audits 研究审查

Physics → Statistical Mechanics物理学 → 统计物理与非平衡热力学

C. Jarzynski · 1997

Nonequilibrium Equality for Free Energy Differences

Physical Review Letters 78, 2690–2693

Reviewed — Limited Scope已完成限定范围数学审查

Scientific significance 科学重要性

The paper connects nonequilibrium work statistics with equilibrium free-energy differences.

该研究将非平衡功统计与平衡自由能差建立了重要联系。重要性说明不替代数学正确性证据。

Physical-to-mathematical reconstruction 物理—数学转换

  1. Physical Problem物理问题
  2. Mathematical Formulation数学问题构造
  3. Decisive Derivation决定性推导
  4. Conditions & Counterexamples成立条件与反例

Under specified assumptions, an exponential work average becomes a ratio of partition functions through canonical weighting and a measure-preserving transformation.

在明确假设下,初始正则权重与保测度变换,使指数功平均转化为配分函数之比。

The audit covers selected claims, not the entire paper or all experiments. It is not evidence that the Skill independently solved an unguided research problem.审查只覆盖指定命题,不代表全文或全部实验验证;也不说明 Skill 自主解决了一个未经指导的科研问题。

Physics → Nonlinear Dynamics → Synchronization物理学 → 非线性动力学 → 同步

E. Ott and T. M. Antonsen · 2008

Low dimensional behavior of large systems of globally coupled oscillators

Chaos 18, 037113

Reviewed — Limited Scope已完成限定范围数学审查

Low-dimensional collective dynamics motivates a precise question: can the same initial first-harmonic information produce opposite synchronization trends outside the OA manifold?

从集体动力学降维出发:OA 流形外,相同初始一阶 Fourier 信息能否对应相反的同步增长方向?

For the specified finite positive Poisson-mixture class, the independent study proves a sharp attainable initial-growth interval, constructs smooth admissible densities and gives opposite-sign examples.

独立研究在指定有限正 Poisson 混合初态类内,证明瞬时增长率的锐可达区间,完成合法光滑密度提升与反向增长反例。

Independent Mathematical Reconstruction: ACCEPTED AFTER MINOR REVISIONS独立数学重建:完成小修后接受

Research used v0.2.12; archived in v0.2.13. The acceptance concerns this reconstruction, not all paper results or the authors. Originality, empirical/physical validation and incremental Skill gain: NOT ESTABLISHED. The duration-of-growth bound remains unexecuted.

接受限于本案例重建;不评定原论文或作者。原创性、经验物理验证和 Skill 增量优势未建立,增长持续时间下界尚未执行。

Conditional mathematical research / 条件性数学研究

Research in Progress 进行中科研案例

Angioni et al. · 2012

Off-diagonal particle and toroidal momentum transport: a survey of experimental, theoretical and modelling aspects

Nuclear Fusion 52, 114003 (2012)

C1 and C2 exploratory mathematical studies completed and conditionally reviewed; incremental Skill capability gain not established.C1、C2 探索性数学研究已完成并经条件性审查;Skill 增量能力尚未证明。

Source evidence & attribution 原文证据与贡献来源

Codex Stage A extracted source evidence; the initial ChatGPT review retains its separate historical attribution. The later C1 and C2 reports used frozen Skill v0.2.7 and v0.2.8 through explicit Git-blob reads, not native Skill invocation. The project owner's subsequent ChatGPT mathematical-content decisions are recorded separately from engineering checks.

原文证据来自 Codex 阶段 A,初步 ChatGPT 评议保留独立历史归属。后续 C1、C2 报告分别显式读取冻结 Skill v0.2.7、v0.2.8 的 Git blob,非原生 Skill 调用。项目负责人在 ChatGPT 中完成的数学内容审查决策与工程检查分别记录。

C1 — Momentum Transport Identifiability 动量输运可识别性

Can observations separate diffusion, pinch and residual stress? Explicit shared-parameter assumptions yield rank conditions and error bounds; arbitrary residual changes permit non-unique decompositions. The same rotation profile can arise from different cancelling contributions. Omitted-term bias may be zero or have either sign; zero fit residual does not ensure correct identification.

观测能否分离扩散、pinch 与 residual stress?明确共享参数条件下得到秩条件及误差界;允许残余项任意变化则分解不唯一。同一旋转剖面可由不同贡献抵消实现。遗漏项偏差可为零,方向不固定;零拟合残差不保证正确识别。

Conditional Mathematical Review — Accepted with Limitations条件性数学审查:附限制接受

Least-squares formulas are unconstrained; positive estimated diffusion requires a separate constrained treatment. The C1 session had reference-review exposure.最小二乘公式为无约束估计;估计扩散严格为正需另作约束处理。C1 会话曾接触参考评议。

C2 — Density Gradient Self-Consistency 密度梯度自洽性

Does state-dependent particle transport admit a unique zero-flux density gradient? Conditional proofs give existence, uniqueness and root-perturbation bounds on a specified interval and state branch. Positive diffusion and inward non-diagonal drive still allow three distinct roots in a mathematical counterexample. A non-monotone peaking–frequency association does not prove multiple self-consistent roots under the same background.

状态依赖粒子输运是否存在唯一零通量密度梯度?条件性证明给出指定区间与状态分支上的存在性、唯一性和根扰动界。数学反例表明,正扩散与向内非对角驱动仍允许三个不同的根。非单调峰化—频率关联不能直接证明同一背景下存在自洽多解。

Conditional Mathematical Review — Accepted条件性数学审查:接受

Artificial closures are not validated ITG/TEM models. Root-perturbation bounds do not establish dynamical stability or actual tokamak multiplicity.人为闭合不是已验证的 ITG/TEM 模型;根扰动界不证明动力学稳定性或真实托卡马克多解。

No raw experimental reanalysis, full-paper validation, journal peer review or fully independent external refereeing is claimed. No credible Skill OFF control; Skill incremental gain: NOT ESTABLISHED. Physical closure and device validation remain open; These cases are not included in Reviewed Papers.未重新分析原始实验,不冒称全文验证、期刊同行评审或完全独立外审。没有可信 Skill OFF 对照,增量能力尚未证明。完整物理闭合与装置验证仍待完成;这些案例不计入已审查论文数量。

Fable et al. · 2010

Electron Density Transport and ITG/TEM Spectral Response 电子密度输运与 ITG/TEM 谱响应

Physical source: Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 52, 015007 (2010)

Research Question 研究问题

What determines the stationary electron-density gradient's conditional responses to electron and ion temperature gradients in ITG/TEM turbulence?

在 ITG/TEM 湍流背景下,定态电子密度梯度对电子温度梯度和离子温度梯度的条件响应由哪些因素决定?

Mathematical Progress 数学进展

  • Derived both conditional responses from the paper's quasi-linear flux decomposition.从原文准线性通量分解推导两种条件响应。
  • Separated direct temperature-gradient drive from modal-coefficient and spectral-weight feedback.区分直接温度梯度驱动、单模系数变化和谱权重反馈。
  • Proved sufficient response-ordering criteria with explicit margins, including conditions for the opposite ordering.证明带明确余量的排序充分条件及相反排序条件。
  • Constructed a mathematical counterexample with the same mean frequency but different response orderings.构造平均频率相同而响应排序可改变的数学反例。
  • Distinguished fixed-alpha and pressure-recomputed-alpha control protocols.区分固定 alpha 与按压力梯度重算 alpha 的控制协议。

Research Status 研究状态

Conditional Mathematical Review — Accepted with Limitations.条件性数学审查:附限制接受。

Physical Validation 物理验证

Actual gyrokinetic response ordering: NOT ESTABLISHED.实际 gyrokinetic 响应排序:尚未建立。

The three-wavenumber counterexample is mathematical; realizability by a genuine gyrokinetic eigenproblem is unconfirmed. No new simulations or HL-3 data reanalysis; this review is not author endorsement, journal peer review or complete independent physical validation.三波数反例的真实本征谱可实现性未确认;未运行新模拟或重分析 HL-3 数据。本审查不代表作者认可、期刊同行评审或完整独立物理验证。

Skill Evidence Skill 证据

Exploratory Skill-guided research completed by explicit Git blob loading of frozen v0.2.9, not native invocation; incremental capability gain NOT ESTABLISHED.探索性研究显式读取冻结 v0.2.9 Git blob,非原生调用;无可信 Skill OFF 对照,增量优势尚未建立。

Research objective / 科研目标

What This Skill Does 这个 Skill 做什么

Bring a scientific phenomenon, observations, a model or an open question. The Skill helps formulate general mathematical questions, complete feasible analysis and identify next mathematical steps for unresolved parts. No laboratory or simulation software is required; unverified physical applicability is labelled, with optional validation routes.

提供科学现象、观测、模型或未解决问题,Skill 帮助构造一般数学问题、实际推进可行分析,并给出未解决部分的下一数学动作。无需实验装置或模拟软件;未经验证的物理适用性须明确标注,可说明可选验证途径。

  1. Physical Phenomenon物理现象
  2. Mathematical Formulation数学问题构造
  3. Task-relevant Result任务相关数学结果
  4. Conditions成立条件
  5. Counterexamples & Boundaries反例与边界
  6. Testable Consequences可检验后果

This is a research objective, not a mandatory reasoning pipeline or a guarantee of success.

这是项目的研究目标,不是强制推理流水线,也不是成功保证。

The canonical Skill contains four Core rules and six observable audit requirements; these are instructions and a result-audit contract, not measured performance. Discipline adapters remain optional and experimental.现行 Skill 包含四条 Core 与六项可观察审计要求:它们是规范及结果审查契约,不是性能评分。学科适配仍为可选实验性指导。

Canonical Skill / 运行规范 →

Methods & Sources / 方法与来源

Public materials from OpenAI Math, Mathlib4 and Physlib reviewed; method adoption remains under evaluation. No proof replication, method integration or measured Skill gain established.已初步查阅公开资料,方法迁移待评估;未完成证明复现、方法集成或科研增量验证,不代表合作或背书。

Read source records and limits / 阅读来源记录与限制 →

Voluntary participation / 自愿参与

Community Participation 社区参与

Share physical-to-mathematical cases, corrections to existing audits, counterexamples, unresolved propositions or reproducible Skill failures. Authors are welcome to join voluntarily; no author participation or endorsement is implied.

欢迎提供物理—数学转换案例、修正已有审查、提交反例或未解决的命题,以及可复现的 Skill 失败案例。欢迎原作者自愿参与,不暗示作者已经参加、赞同或认可。

This observatory summarizes committed evidence; it is not a separate source of scientific facts. Records are updated manually with versioned repository changes.看板是已提交证据的可视化摘要,不是新的独立事实来源;内容随仓库版本更新手动维护。